Tuesday, July 22, 2008

Blind Salamanders and Unintelligent Design

Christopher Hitchens has posted a thought-provoking essay on Slate about "Losing Sight of Progress." He discusses how salamanders living in subterranean caverns are born with eyes that cannot see. Then he uses this fact to deconstruct faith in "creation science" and "intelligent design." Hitchens shared this insight with Richard Dawkins and received this response:
Vestigial eyes, for example, are clear evidence that these cave salamanders must have had ancestors who were different from them—had eyes, in this case. That is evolution. Why on earth would God create a salamander with vestiges of eyes? If he wanted to create blind salamanders, why not just create blind salamanders? Why give them dummy eyes that don't work and that look as though they were inherited from sighted ancestors?
Hitchens and Dawkins have got a point. I doubt that either creation scientists or intelligent designers can make a satisfactory response to this.

I believe in a creator, but find abhorrent theories like "creation science" and "intelligent design" which prescribe that creation necessarily requires supernatural interventions. All such prescriptions conceal attempts to make both science and God conform to the theorists conception of scriptural hermeneutics.

The Infinite is free to create all the processes of the finite order to accomplish the purposes of Eternity. There's little need for a conflict of interpretations between faith and science. There is much need for a faith that knows how to appropriate the truth that science discovers.

It seems to me that blind salamanders are a good illustration of the folly of prefering darkness to light (John 3:19). These salamanders turned from the light and bred in darkness until they became blind. They thereby condemned their children to live in a very small, dark and confined world -- more like a prison than like the free ranging, wide open spaces of the world above ground.

I suspect that safety and homeland security were on the minds of those first salamanders that fell into their cave. They must have been frightened into that cave by some threat that towered over them. Who can blame them if they found it too traumatizing to climb back to daylight and face the world with their eyes wide open?

If they stayed in the cave until they grew accustomed to their cramped quarters and then went blind, at least they never had to face the terrors they met in the daylight.

And those vestigal blind eyes do have a purpose. They serve as a constant reminder that their progeny will never know what it was like to live in the light.

No comments: