Enron's accountants didn't wave a red flag. Investment bankers didn't balk. Lawyers didn't object. The big banks didn't withhold cash. Credit analysts didn't downgrade the investment rating. Wall Street analysts didn't raise doubts.
And the news media, which had no financial incentive to pump up the Enron story, nonetheless never challenged the notion that the company was one of the great innovators.
The Securities and Exchange Commission didn't scrutinize Enron's financial reports, either -- until it was too late. But the agency did issue rulings that allowed Enron to bolster its numbers (with mark-to-market accounting) and enter the utility business, where it ultimately ripped off California for billions of dollars.
For those who still think "less government oversight" and "deregulation" is the cure for all that ails our society, here's another quote:
Is it a coincidence that hundreds of savings and loans went belly up after deregulation? A similar pattern emerged in telecommunications, with the frauds at Global Crossing and WorldCom. Enron's rise and fall paralleled the deregulation of natural gas and utilities.
Even airline deregulation, an unquestioned boon for consumers, had a price-fixing scandal.
Of course, this doesn't mean that every company cheats and steals when its industry deregulates. But it's a good bet that many players go too far -- and that the public can't rely on private checks and balances to save the day.
Whatever happened to the Calvinist doctrine of total depravity? Why do so many capitalists think corporations will act in ways that are less depraved than individuals?
Frankly, my experience shows that the reverse is true. Ken Lay, private individual, would never think of robbing a bank while Ken Lay, CEO, didn't think twice about rigging energy markets to bankrupt "grandma's" in California.
No comments:
Post a Comment