Thursday, August 10, 2006

On the Power of Blogging

When Frank Page was elected President of the Southern Baptist Convention there was a lot of talk about how "blogging" would move the SBC back to the center.

Now that Ned Lamont has defeated Joe Lieberman in a Connecticut Democratic primary there is a lot of talk that "netroots" will move the Democratic party to the left.

Both predictions are exaggerated.

Ari Melber's essay in Nation magazine on, "Ned Lamont's Digital Constituency" provides a lot of helpful perspective. Here's a quote:

Some independent experts also see the recent attacks on bloggers as just campaign tactics. "Lieberman's best chance is to convince people that his opponents are extremists, and people who are unsophisticated in politics associate extremism with vitriolic behavior," explained Michael Cornfield, an assoicate research professor at George Washington University who studies Internet politics. Cornfield stressed that there is "no ideological bent" to netroots activists; the recent talk of bloggers pulling the party left relies on stereotypes, not data. Lee Rainie, director of the Pew Internet & American Life Project, said surveys indicate that blog readers tend to be "engaged citizens" who are more likely to vote and participate in civic activities, but that there is no "significant partisan skewing" in the blogosphere.
My own experience in the blogosphere indicates that the internet is decidedly not skewed toward the left. In fact, the number of fundamentalists in the Christian blogosphere significantly exceeds the number of moderates and progressives.

Want some evidence? See if you can find any moderate or progressive seminary in the world that can match the number of bloggers that Al Mohler is cultivating at Southern Seminary.

5 comments:

momly said...

Hmm. Mostly white, young, and male.

R. Mansfield said...

You're making up conspiracies where they don't exist. I have a blog listed on sbtsblogs.net, and I can assure you that I was never encouraged by Mohler or anyone else in the administration to add my blog to the list. In fact, I had my blog for two years before I decided to go back to school and finish my degree. I happened to see a link to sbtsblogs.net on another student's blog and decided to check it out for myself.

Could it be that SBTS has more bloggers than any moderate or progressive seminary simply because SBTS has more students than any moderate or progressive seminary?

Timmy Brister said...

Let me echo that of Mr. Mansfield and say that Dr. Mohler hasn't cultivated SBTS blogs at all. It has the life of its own. Before making such statements, it would be wise that you check your sources before leaping to such assumptions.

Stephen Newell said...

Never mind the fact that most of us had blogs long before we discovered the SBTS blogroll.

Unknown said...

I have a blog listed on sbtsblogs.net. Neither Al Mohler nor my husband, who's a student at SBTS, are "cultivating" me to write a blog, let alone to include my blog there. Your insinuation of such is offensive to me as a woman and as someone who has an independent mind. I listed my blog for the same reason that other folks do -- to get as much exposure as possible.